Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Nancy Keeler

Your Advantage in Northwest Indiana

Strategic Guidance Backed by Nearly Three Decades of Experience

Known for her integrity and dedication, Nancy Keeler provides a tailored approach backed by years of experience, helping you move forward with confidence.

29 Years

Real Estate Excellence

522+

Total Sales

5 ★

Google and Zillow Reviews

Home Search

Home Valuation

Let's Connect
Meet Nancy

Meet Nancy

Real Estate Agent

With nearly 30 years of experience, Nancy Keeler brings a uniquely analytical approach to the Northwest Indiana real estate market. Her background in Microbiology has instilled in her a rigorous attention to detail and a data-driven approach that she applies to every transaction, ensuring her clients have a distinct advantage in a competitive field.

As a lifelong Northwest Indiana resident, Nancy has witnessed the region’s remarkable evolution—from its vast, open landscapes to the vibrant, connected communities of today. This deep-rooted connection allows her to guide her clients with both historical context and forward-looking insight.

Nancy’s approach is built on a foundation of refined strategy and unwavering support. She believes that real estate is not just about the transaction; it is about prioritizing her clients' goals through clear communication and expert negotiation. Whether you are ready to plant roots in a new neighborhood or planning a transition to their next chapter, Nancy is committed to managing every detail to ensure a seamless experience from start to finish.

 

Learn More
WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

We have worked with and recommended Nancy for several years. Her knowledge and experience have guided us well. She truly puts her clients' best interests first.

— Jeannie G.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy really knows her stuff! Her experience in the business really paid off for us in our home sale. This was our fourth time selling a house, and Nancy was by far the best realtor that we have worked with. Always available, smart, well-connected in the business, and quick. She really knows how to get the job done! You will not be disappointed!

— Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy was very knowledgeable and professional in helping stage and sell my home. She made what can be a difficult and stressful time go smoothly with an excellent result.

— Altoeva

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy was very knowledgeable about property details, including preparing the house for sale and involving steps in the sale process. She was always able to locate and contact the right individuals needed to process the property sale. I would use Nancy again in the future if needed for a home sale.

— Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy listed and sold our home in less than two weeks. We couldn’t be happier with her attention to detail and professionalism. She is very knowledgeable and answered all our questions during the process. We would definitely recommend her to anyone wanting to buy or sell a home. Thank you, Nancy Keeler.

— Dalton

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Ana is an awesome and knowledgeable realtor. I have used her to both purchase and sell a property. She kept me updated through every step of the process for both transactions. I would highly recommend her.

— Buyer & Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Having not sold or purchased a home in 40 years, Nancy explained everything during our first meeting and guided us throughout the entire process. We feel she went above and beyond to make our sale happen despite numerous challenges. We felt comfortable leaving details in her capable hands. We are very happy to have worked with Nancy.

— Lisa V.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

If you are buying or selling your home, you need Nancy. Nancy helped us sell two houses and buy our forever home. She came out, walked through our homes, and gave recommendations on where to upgrade and how to set up for selling. We had an offer on our first sale in 7 days and an offer on our second sale in 5 days. Nancy made buying our forever home extremely easy. We cannot tell you enough about how won...

— Aaron W.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

I have had the pleasure of working with Nancy with multiple homebuyers. Nancy does an incredible job of keeping the interests of her clients at the forefront of every part of the negotiation and home search process. When discussing how to prepare a home for sale, she delivers sound advice on what the highest return on investment strategies a seller should consider. Nancy is adept at working with both fir...

— Chris C.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy was an incredible partner in selling my home and finding our new one! Thanks to her expertise and strategic approach, we received an offer in just four days. Even when she had personal commitments, she ensured we were fully supported by having someone from her team available at all times. Her professionalism, dedication, and seamless communication made the entire process stress-free. I couldn’t rec...

— A. G.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

We were referred to Nancy Keeler on Zillow after clicking through on a house we wanted to see. We had no prior knowledge of Nancy but were extremely impressed with her professionalism and character right off the bat. She was able to help us both buy and sell our homes seamlessly. She went above and beyond to through out the entire process. We highly recommend, Nancy Keeler for your home buying and sellin...

— Buyer & Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy is definitely my go to realtor. She has helped myself and other family and friends with purchasing and selling properties over the years. She is so knowledgeable and trustworthy. She fights for her clients and is always available to answer your questions. I highly recommend Nancy when you are ready to buy or sell.

— Buyer & Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy’s experience was second to none when it came to putting our home up for sale. 1. Nancy took the time to understand our situation fully and listen to what we expected. 2. Nancy was able to use her knowledge to inform us upfront about what we could expect and where we may need to compromise. 3. Nancy communicated openly and promptly and was available to us 24/7. Nancy always returned our phone calls ...

— Rob

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy has been great to work with! She is on top of everything and quickly helped us find the right location and place! She made finding our home easy!

— Buyer

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

I was nervous about trying to sell a home in the beginning of the Covid situation. Nancy was extremely professional and careful with the handling of showings and dealing with my anxieties of myself. She had a bunch of interest drummed up from day 1 and really made the selling process an easy one! Would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!!! 10/10

— Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

I was a first time homebuyer and Nancy helped me out. She is a great realtor, very knowledgeable and made the entire process very easy for me! I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking to buying a home.

— Buyer

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy has been in the business a long time. Very personable and knowledgeable. I wasn’t sure what I was looking for in a home and she was patient showing me many homes until we narrowed it down. She figured out my style and found me the perfect place.

— Janice L.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

As a first time "single" home buyer, I was quite nervous about the entire process... Nancy helped take the stress out of buying a house... Her knowledge and know how, honesty and transparency, made for an overall positive experience! If you're looking to buy a house, I would highly recommend Nancy! Nancy is a trusted professional!

— Buyer

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy sold our home on the first day of listing it and helped me on the purchase of my new home. Nancy is always readily available to answer all questions and concerns. My wife and I were very happy with Nancy through the whole process. We highly recommended Nancy for all your real estate needs.

— Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

We were referred to her by a family friend based on her character. We knew nothing of her experience. From our first contact via phone she was so easy to talk with and very reassuring that we would have no trouble selling our home despite the pandemic climate. We trusted her immediately. Nancy never broke that trust. This was our first time selling a home (owners for 30 years). She guided us through each...

— Seller

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

When we needed to sell our house I contacted Nancy right away. She helped us sell my mother-in-law’s house 2 years ago. She is honest, hardworking and very response. I completely trust in her expertise.

— Irene

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Nancy sold my brother a house about 18 years ago and I was so impressed with her that I called her when I was looking to buy my townhome two years ago! Nancy is very helpful, very knowledgeable and very professional! She always returned my calls promptly and made sure she had an answer for me. Nancy is so much fun to work with!

— Sherry W.

View All Testimonials

Browse My Portfolio

Sold

7761 E Miller Ln
$680,000

7761 East Miller, LnHOBART, IN 46342

  • 3 BEDS
  • 3 BATHS
  • 3,960 Sq.Ft.

Sold

1119 Treadway Rd
$650,000

1119 Treadway Road, Munster, IN 46321

  • 5 BEDS
  • 5 BATHS
  • 4,459 Sq.Ft.

Sold

1119 Treadway Road
$650,000

1119 Treadway Road, Munster, IN 46321

  • 5 BEDS
  • 5 BATHS
  • 4,459 Sq.Ft.

Sold

290 S Fieldstone Dr
$634,900

290 South Fieldstone Drive, Hebron, IN 46341

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 2,156 Sq.Ft.

Sold

290 S Fieldstone Drive
$634,900

290 S Fieldstone Drive, Hebron, IN 46341

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 2,156 Sq.Ft.
View All Properties

Neighborhood Guides

Munster

Read More

Crown Point

Read More

Dyer

Read More

Schererville

Read More

Saint John

Read More

Highland

Read More

Griffith

Read More

Cedar Lake

Read More

Valparaiso

Read More

Lowell

Read More
View All Neighborhoods

How Much is Your Home Worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more
Form Image

Get Early Access to New Listings

Sign up to get updates on the latest listings, neighborhood trends, and local real estate insights.

Thank You!

Find all current listings available

See Your Listing

Work With Nancy

Nancy Keeler provides expert real estate support, helping clients with pricing, offers, contracts, and negotiations. With over 29 years of experience in Northwest Indiana, she ensures a smooth and successful buying or selling process tailored to each client’s needs.

Let's Connect
Get in Touch
Contact Details

NANCY KEELER

(219) 313-5003

[email protected]

 

ADDRESS

2211 Main St Ste 2C
Highland, IN 46322